A blue-green powerhouse
Meet This Excelsior Cyan In A New Way With A Pigment Code Cheat Sheet to Decode This True Blue
A blue-green powerhouse
Phthalo blue: cyan skies, blue lagoons, and teals galore. This transparent paint comes out of the tube almost black in some cases, but just a drop of oil or a touch of white will electrify its chroma. Powerful in both glazes and mixes, this is one of the most intense colors on the painter's palette, and some thought must be given to its use. However, it is hard to imagine what painters of the past would have given for such a clear cyan. Phthalo blue has a bit of complexity to it, but we are fortunate that there is a way to decode the differences between the varieties.
More chromatic than Prussian blue, generally more green-leaning than Ultramarine, and overall more powerful than the gentler genuine Cerulean, we'd consider this an essential color to the palette.
There are two main forms of Phthalo Blue, which are sometimes labeled Phthalo Green Red Shade or Green Shade, though both are solidly blue. This refers to the way the colors mix as the slight leaning to each color will make one or the other more suitable in different color-mixing applications. Phthalo Blue has a handful of variations which can thankfully be disentangled by an additional number that may follow the pigment code, such as PB15:1. The most common varieties are PB15:1 (red shade) and PB15:3 (green shade), however we'll talk about the others, too.
Phthalo Blue among other blue pigments from Cornelissen. Phthalo Blue can be used with numerous binders.
Notes on the usage and varieties of Phthalo Blue from the Great Book of Color. Phthalo Blue can be almost black out of the tube, or lighter blue as in the Manganese Blue imitations, which are often made of Phthalo.
How to work with Phthalo Blue
This powerful blue-green may actually be too intense for some. This blue packs such a punch that we hear even the pigment comes diluted with an extender, as we suspect in this version of dry pigment from Sennelier. When binder is added though the pigment appears much darker.
For this pigment, the usual strategy of judging paint quality by tinting strength is less applicable, since some painters actually find the baseline strength a bit too strong. Here are a couple of ways to tame phthalo:
We recommend "cutting the mix" with other pigments which are amenable to the final mix. Cutting the mix means using a palette knife to cut a small quantity of the color into another color and keeping the blend on the palette. Phthalo can be cut with any color, but we find mixes with white, green, or ultramarine could be useful depending on how a person intends to use it.
A painter can also use a palette knife to just tap the Phthalo and get a dot of it on the knife. This gives an artist more control than using a brush sometimes, which can be possibly a bit harder to wield. A toothpick-sized dot of phthalo can sometimes make its presence known!
Some painters like to use student versions of phthalo as they may be less intense, however we don't recommend this as a first strategy since sometimes student brands come with other additives which are not the greatest.
Consider the blue for the task. If a person is doing a lot of realistic portraiture or landscape work (think Old Master's style), it's going to take more mixing down to get the phthalo look out of the mix. It can certainly be done, however we've come to prefer genuine Cerulean Blue (PB35) for more realistic work as it mixes differently than Phthalo.
However, for a limited palette, Phthalo Blue is an extraordinary color, and the chroma is outstanding.
Phthalo Blue pigment from Sennelier
Sometimes Paint Companies just give us the bare minimum
There are many paints which are just labeled PB15. This makes it trickier for painters to determine whether they are selecting red shade or green shade. We appreciate it when paintmakers add the additional number after the colon, however there are some good paints which lack the more specific labeling.
Paints marked PB15 without a colon afterwards. These could be any of the phthalo varieties, and one must appeal to the paint name to make a guess as to their properties.
Red Shade, Blue Shade, and Mystery Shades- Decoding the World of Phthalos
Ok, so normally we like mystery. But not when it comes to our Phthalo Blues, which can often be sorted out by adding a number to the pigment code. PB15 without an additional number means we are dealing with a mystery phthalo. Phthalo Blue comes in a handful of varieties which have different properties, and sometimes paintmakers don't specify them. The general pigment code for Phthalo Blue (this is the little letter-number combo printed on the back of the tube) is PB15. With phthalos there is sometimes an additional level of information-a colon with a number added to the code- which can tell a person more about its specific properties.
This additional colon is helpful for painters. While the two main varieties of phthalo are similar, they behave differently in mixes.
Here's a short run-down of the phthalos:
Phthalo Blue Red Shade - Most commonly PB15:0 or PB15:1. However we've seen any variety of Phthalo sometimes labeled Red Shade.
Phthalo Blue Green Shade - Almost always PB15:3
Here is a brief synopsis of the various Phthalo Blue pigment codes:
PB15:0 - A rare version of Phthalo Blue that is redder (in the one instance we know of it's labeled as Red Shade).
PB15:1 - A common version of Phthalo Blue (Red Shade)
PB15:2 - A rare version of Phthalo Blue that seems warmer, more like Red Shade. In the past, this type was used by Gamblin, and is currently used in Old Holland's Scheveningen Blue Deep.
PB15:3 - A common version of Phthalo Blue (Green Shade). Excellent for making teal mixes.
PB15:4 - We associate this with a more delicate cyan. It's commonly used in Manganese Blue Imitations. In one case it's labeled Red Shade, however in other cases it's labeled Turquoise. We've almost always seen it as a green-leaning clear cyan.
PB15:6 - In one case labeled Red Shade. May have slightly less reliable lightfastness, but we have not tested it specifically. It's a slightly different form of Phthalo than the others listed above.
For these mystery Phthalos, the paint name is the best clue to their nature, as they do not include the extra colon (e.g. PB15:3), and just label the colors PB15.
A look at some popular Phthalo Blues in Oil Paint
We compared several Phthalo Blues across brands in our Phthalo Blue Comparison. Almost all of the paints we compared are Phthalo Blue Green Shade, PB15:3 (however there's a PB15:1, in there, too).
Phthalo Blues vary a bit in terms of color temperature in tints. However, Phthalos are one of the places where binding oils may also make a difference. Though it forms the strongest paint films, linseed oil does yellow. Tints of phthalo are an area of the gamut where painters will try to preserve more of the true bright cyan blue color, though this must be done carefully (be sure to do your research if you choose to use safflower or poppy oil-- we can't recommend using these in the lower layers of a painting). However with safflower there may be a tiny chroma boost, so there may be a case for using it judiciously if you understand the risks.
Among the varieties of Phthalo, we prize the Phthalo Blue Green Shade PB15:3 most for its ability to create bright cyan tints as well as teals. On this panel, the paint to the far right is a Red Shade, while the others on the panel are Green Shade. Paintmakers will formulate the PB15:3 with different working consistencies, so even though the pigment codes are the same, each brand has a different viscosity. More details about the paints on this panel can be found in our Comparison of Phthalo Blue Paints.
Several Phthalo Blues across brands. Most of these are Phthalo Blue Green Shade (PB15:3), though the one on the far right is Red Shade.
In poppy, walnut, safflower oil, or a blend of linseed and safflower, these options have less linseed oil
The brightest cyan in modern oil paints
Beautiful Phthalo Blues
Confusing Names for Two Blues
The convention of Green Shade and Red Shade is a bit of a wild one, but we see similar patterns in the way other pigments are named. In general the Green Shade makes the best teals. The Red Shade is a bit more of a middle blue. Here the Gamblin, RGH, and Old Holland Blue Lake are listed as PB15:1 or Red Shade. It's interesting to note the difference with the lighter tinting Vasari Green Shade and Old Holland Scheveningen Blue, both PB15:3.
Phthalo Blue Red Shade and Green Shade show their differences in tints
From the Great Book of Color - Phthalo Blue Red Shade
Phthalo Blue Red Shade isn't always labeled in the paint name, so it's helpful to know the pigments
From the Great Book of Color
Sometimes a delicate cyan, we associate this pigment with Manganese Blue Imitations (for more see below)
A rare form of Phthalo Blue
Sometimes paintmakers add other pigments to make a Manganese Blue facsimile. However the heavy lifters here are often Phthalos
These mixes explore the variety of color transitions with green that can be achieved with phthalo blue and contrast them with a few other blues on the palette.
Phthalo Blue compared with other blues and purples in mixes with greens
Several Questions to Ask Before Choosing a Blue
Will the paint be used in the lower layers of the painting? If so, consider a phthalo blue bound only in linseed oil.
Are you looking for the brightest cyans or teals? We recommend Phthalo Blue Green Shade (PB15:3) for mixing the brightest blue-greens.
And if the phthalo is too intense, consider cutting the mix with another color. Complements to phthalo which can also tone it back are oranger versions of PR101 and Cadmium Orange PO20.